A Covert Video Primer

From GovernmentVideo.com: "They include cameras hidden in “Exit” signs, electric utility boxes and even the lid of an actual spring water bottle. And that’s not all: covert video cameras and camcorders are also available inside wristwatches, ballpoint pens, smoke detectors, cordless phones, calculators, teddy bears—virtually anything.

It is easy to see how covert technology could be of use to government video professionals; not just for law enforcement, but internal office security, remote site supervision and even “reality TV” productions for training/promotional purposes.

But before a wristwatch camera—available for $59.99 at thinkgeek.com—starts recording, anyone shooting covert video would be wise to first know the rules of covert video.


The first question that needs to be answered before firing up the wristwatch camcorder is, “why am I shooting this video?” The reason that needs to be answered is because there are different rules governing covert video, depending on whether you are shooting it as a private individual/business, or on behalf of a government agency.

“If you are doing it for yourself or a private business, there are not too many rules,” says Grant Fredericks, who is one of North America’s most respected forensic video experts. Fredericks is a former police officer who now owns and operates Forensic Video Solutions in Spokane, Wash.

“Generally, you are allowed to use hidden cameras at home and at work, subject to privacy laws. For instance, you cannot put hidden cameras in change rooms and bathrooms,” he said. In addition, there are also 13 states—Alabama, Arkansas, California, Delaware, Georgia, Hawaii, Kansas, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, South Dakota and Utah—that do not allow surveillance video to be shot in private locations without the consent of those being watched.

In contrast, covert video shot on behalf of a government agency falls under tougher federal and state laws; the latter of which vary from state to state. The rule of thumb is this: Areas where people are in “public view” are generally considered legally-acceptable places for shooting covert video. “However, this only applies to video,” Fredericks warns. “To capture audio legally anywhere, you need to have a warrant. And you need to have this warrant before you start your surveillance—especially if you intend to use the video in court.”


Be aware that any video shot could end up being used in legal proceedings (even if it is to fight a nuisance suit filed by someone who resents being recorded in public view). Therefore, it is good to know what the local laws are governing the storage of surveillance footage.

“In most states, having an accurate digital copy of the original footage, such that it can be forensically shown not to have been tampered with, is good enough,” Fredericks says. “Again, you need to check before you start shooting. And make sure that you store a full copy of the raw footage, not an edited version. It could be argued that the footage you cut out could have proven the innocence of the person being observed, whether or not that was actually the case,” he adds.

In addition, it is important to keep careful written records (e.g., audit trail) of the steps taken to capture and record the covert video, says Elliott Goldstein, a Canadian lawyer who has authored a book entitled, Visual Evidence: A Practitioners Manual. Goldstein, a Canadian authority, suggests that such records should document the obtaining of authority (judicial warrant or court authorization); list the equipment used (camera, lens, set up and calibration, etc.); identify the media (DVR, DVD, videotape, flash card, hard disk, etc.) and format (e.g., JPEG, MPEG, etc.) used to capture of the images; and document the chain of custody of the evidence from the time the recording was made until it was brought to court.

If covert video is enhanced (e.g., to increase contrast, to remove blur and sharpen focus, correct color, etc.) then both the original source video (the “Before” video) and the enhanced version (the “After” video) must be provided to the judge to determine admissibility. Goldstein calls that the “Before and After” rule. Lastly, remember to properly safeguard any evidence admitted in court, should there be an appeal. All covert video exhibits admitted into evidence must be retained for the proper statutory period, with the length of storage depending upon the state rules regarding exhibits, or any court order ..."

Click here to continue reading this story.


This is


Post a Comment

All comments and feedback appreciated!

Criminology & Justice Headline Animator


Law Books




Serial Killers



Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...